Bloggers... I need design advice!!

TL and I are in a little dilemma, we can't decide which chairs we want to eventually put in a sitting are in our house, or if we should at all.  After a few hours of searching, sitting, and debating... we have finally decided on one type of chair we hope to get soon (although, I am also going to show you the one I like, tell me what you think).  We can't figure out what color!!

Here are some pictures of our family room/dining room so you can get an idea of the surroundings: (please excuse the bareness of it, I'm still trying to figure out the decorating!)

{The colors are neutral and pretty natural.  The walls are a yellowish-khaki color, and all the molding is white.  We have some yellows and a few greens to bring in a little color, but it's all in the few accessories.}

 See the big open space in front of the window... that's where we want the two chairs.

Colors in dining room - all pretty neutral - but more beige. 

Here's a picture during the day so you can see the true color with out the flash. (This was move in day pre furniture)

The chairs would have about 8-10 feet of space.

What do you think would look good:

{Chair One}

These chairs would go to the top of the white squares in the window - they aren't as tall as they look.

in what color??

 Ivory

Harbor Blue

Washed Metal Grey

Ember

Or This: {TL hates these chairs - says we should live in a medieval castle}

{but with white wood or black wood??}

They are a little shorter, but almost same height as chair one.

In which color?

More khaki

 Metal Grey

 Funky pattern

Stone blue/grey

TL says he likes the idea of the top chair in a brown leather.

We want to put two together with a small table in the middle of them.

Chair one, chair two, which color, no chair at all??

Or do you have a better idea of what to put there??

I swear I will post the final product, if we ever do it. :)

Thank you!!